## VAR in Scottish Football: The Real Problem
The use of Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology in Scotland has faced widespread criticism. Many fans and experts, including Livingston manager David Martindale, question its effectiveness, arguing that the technology itself is far less problematic than the referees implementing it.
> “The issue isn't VAR itself but the referees who manage the process,” Martindale has expressed, highlighting that poor decision-making undermines the system’s potential.
## Criticism of VAR Implementation
Supporters of Scottish football argue that the application of VAR has been inconsistent and often confusing. Although VAR was introduced to reduce human error, it has sometimes caused frustration due to the delays and controversial decisions it produces.
- VAR was introduced with the intent to increase fairness.
- The technology relies heavily on referee interpretation.
- Multiple high-profile errors have damaged VAR's reputation in Scotland.
## Referees, Not Technology, Need Reform
Experts suggest the focus should shift from blaming VAR technology to improving referee training and decision-making standards. Everyone agrees that if referees were more competent and decisive, VAR could fulfill its purpose effectively.
> “VAR is only as good as the people using it,” said a Scottish sports analyst. “Referees must be better prepared and capable of making clear calls under pressure.”
***
Author's summary: While VAR technology in Scottish football is criticized, the root issue lies in referees’ inconsistent decisions, calling for better officiating rather than abandoning VAR.
more
Daily Mail on MSN — 2025-11-29